For those who identify entirely or primarily as male
"a boy" - I don't like "a man"
0 (0.0%)
I prefer "a boy", but will accept "a man"
1 (8.3%)
either, no preference
0 (0.0%)
I prefer "a man", but will accept "a boy"
6 (50.0%)
"a man" - I don't like "a boy"
3 (25.0%)
Grr, argh, don't call me a boy, that really annoys me!
0 (0.0%)
Grr, argh, don't call any grown man a boy, that really annoys me!
2 (16.7%)
For those who identify entirely or primarily as female
"a girl" - I don't like "a woman"
0 (0.0%)
I prefer "a girl", but will accept "a woman"
3 (27.3%)
either, no preference
0 (0.0%)
I prefer "a woman", but will accept "a girl"
1 (9.1%)
"a woman" - I don't like "a girl"
1 (9.1%)
Grr, atgh, don't call me a girl, that really annoys me!
2 (18.2%)
Grr, argh, don't call any grown woman a girl, that really annoys me!
4 (36.4%)
(no subject)
I grew out of 'boy' a decade or so ago, but would still hesitate to call myself 'man'; not so much due to a genuine doubt that I'm 'properly' grown up, more just because for most of my life 'man' has been a word for people in the generation above me.
Fortunately, of course, modern English is equipped with in-between words such as 'bloke' which don't carry a particular connotation of either maturity or the lack thereof. But I think I wouldn't even use those spontaneously; in contexts where any of these words might be appropriate I tend to use 'person' (e.g. I'm the kind of person who ...).
I suppose if gender was directly relevant to whatever point I was making, I'd go for 'man' before 'boy', and if somebody else called me 'man' I'd feel only a slight incongruity easily suppressed whereas 'boy' would give me worse cognitive dissonance. So I can't quite justify refusing to vote. But none the less, tickybox.
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
I don't think I'd mind a third-party reference to myself; e.g. somebody asking "who was that boy you were with?". Referring to me directly as a "boy" however would be a bit odd, but whether or not it was offensive would depend on intent, it could be demeaning or it could just be jokey.
I can't think of any time where being referred to as a man would trouble me.
(no subject)
Hmm, that's an interesting one, because (assuming I've inferred the context correctly) it faintly implies a connection with "boyfriend", one context in which the syllable "boy" is largely uncontroversial to use even of grown men.
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
Now I've got that awful tune from the Boots adverts in my head. Argh.
(no subject)
Calling a woman a "girl" doesn't, but is generally insulting, especially since it tends to get applied to women such that a man the same age would never be called a "boy" (except with the abovementioned racist connotations).
(no subject)
Technically I will accept people referring to me as girl though: I don't call people out for it. Notably I haven't told Mike not to call me "My girl" in affection. So, I could have ticked pretty much all of the bottom half of your second question :)
(no subject)
I would *prefer* "person" in most contexts.
(no subject)
I quite dislike calling nominally grown-up people 'boys' and 'girls'. I may still do it - it's quite a common thing to do in our society, so I've probably picked up the habit, though I'm trying to train myself out of it. While I may not feel properly grown-up, I *am* an adult, and I feel that adults are not 'boys and girls'.
(no subject)
But "woman" sounds less odd to me than it did, say, five years ago, so I imagine as I get older it'll gradually shift over and become the more natural term in my mind.
(no subject)
(no subject)